Guv sacks provincial engineer
By Ian Flora Ocampo
CITY OF SAN FERNANDO -- The die is cast.
Pampanga Governor Eddie Panlilio dismissed on Monday the provincial engineer in the province following the recommendation by an investigative committee that found the Capitol official guilty of serious dishonesty and falsification of official document.
Provincial Engineer Juanito Macatuno, who is serving a 60-day preventive suspension, has been charged with the alleged offenses for stating in his Personal Data Sheet (PDS) in the Provincial Government that he is a licensed civil engineer.
The committee has found out in its investigation that Macatuno was not telling the truth.
The investigative body composed of Provincial Administrator Vivian Dabu, Human Resources Department head Jesusa Goseco, and Assistant Provincial Legal Officer Joseph Quiambao was tasked to look into the allegation that Macatuno was not a civil engineering graduate of Manuel L. Quezon University (MLQU), as he had stated in his PDS.
The committee called different witnesses to establish the truth. They included Thessani Sumalapao, liaison officer of MLQU; Emma Francisco, officer-in-charge of Records Management Division, Professional Regulations Commission (PRC); Perla Sayana, OIC-Application Division, PRC; Rodelo Mangubat, chief administrative officer, Cash Division, PRC; and Lobella Damian, registrar of Mapua University.
In its investigation, the committee discovered that Macatuno consistently entered in his four PDSs that he was a graduate of Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering at MLQU in 1978 and passed the board examination given in the same year.
"In two of the PDSs, he likewise indicated another school, Mapua, as the school where he graduated with the same civil engineering degree. However, based on school records and ancillary documents submitted by MLQU, particularly his transcript of records, the alumni directory and the commencement exercises program for 1978, Engr. Macatuno was never a member of the graduating class of that year," the committee report stated.
"Comparing the submitted photocopy of his diploma with authentic but unclaimed 1978 diplomas, it was noted that the words 'Acting' written before the title 'University Registrar,' present in the originals, was not found in Engr. Macatuno's certificate. It was further noted that the signatures of the school officials of MLQU had marked differences between the two," it added.
The committee also said records from the Professional Regulations Commission (PRC) show that Macatuno took and passed the board examination for civil engineering. However, it said the same PRC records show that in his application to take the examination, he indicated Mapua as the school from where he graduated, whereas in his permanent record with the PRC he indicated MLQU as his alma mater."
"Ms. Sumalapao categorically denied the possibility of Engr. Macatuno having graduated from MLQU with a degree in civil engineering. She also gave a categorical 'NO' when asked if he graduated with a degree of Master in Public Administration inasmuch as he did not fulfill the prerequisite bachelor's course," the committee stated.
For his part, Macatuno insists that he graduated from MLQU with a degree in civil engineering in 1978. He said he also passed the licensure examination for civil engineer given by the PRC on the same year.
On October 22, Macatuno filed a complaint with the Regional Trial Court here seeking to stop the governor from investigating him for allegedly falsely claiming to have a degree in engineering. He also asked for a P500,000 in damages.
Macatuno stressed that his case was already decided by the Civil Service Commission (CSC) a few years back when former Pampanga governor now Senator Manuel "Lito" Lapid charged him with the same case. He said the CSC had ruled that he was a civil engineering graduate and a licensed civil engineer.
On October 1, Panlilio slapped Macatuno with a 60-day preventive suspension after his office received information from a "concerned citizen" alleging that he did not obtain a college degree. He also charged Macatuno with dishonesty and falsification of public documents
The investigative committee added: "On the matter regarding the document issued by the Civil Service Commission Regional Office 3 and penned by Regional Director Anicia Marasigan-de Lima, the committee said it at best may be called an order issued by CSCROIII not to give due course to the request of Atty. Benalfre Galang, provincial legal officer, province of Pampanga, to investigate Engr. Macatuno."
According to the committee, while it disposed of Galang's request due to lack of evidence, it did not prevent the filing of another complaint if new evidence so warrants."
The panel said: "Engr. Macatuno may have taken the board examination and passed it. However, it does not change the fact that he did not graduate from MLQU. He is not an engineer and is not legally and morally fit to continue occupying the position of provincial engineer in the Province of Pampanga."
Provincial legal officer Maria Elissa Velez said Macatuno was given due process. "If he (Macatuno) feels aggrieved about this, he can always make an appeal," she stressed.